Elk Creek Ranch, Island Park, ID

Elk Creek Ranch, Island Park, ID is noted as part of the Henry’s for Anglers collection of iconic fishing lodges in Idaho. We discovered, quite by chance, three years ago this beautifully rustic lodge and cabins sitting on the bucolic Crow Creek where it meets  Henry’s Fork River. The setting is memorizing, the fishing as explained to us, spectacular. The lodge, cabins and grounds are well maintained exuding the original 19th century charm and warmth that only hand-hewn beams and craftsmanship can provide. However that is not the focus of this article. We appreciate this place for its scenery, and seclusion combined with a comfortable fine dining experience. We again were visiting West Yellowstone and made reservations for diner Wednesday evening (the restaurant offers a different weeknight menu and seating is limited). Although a drive from West Yellowstone (approx. 40 miles) it is worth the travel to experience the nostalgic surroundings and excellent food. Wednesday is prime rib night and not disappointed each was served a large slab of prime rib with au jus, mashed potatoes with gravy and steamed broccoli. The prime rib was tender and juicy, the mashed potatoes excellent with just a hint of being burnished in the oven, with gravy that was mild and not salty. The steamed broccoli was slightly steamed to retain its firmness and taste dribbled with butter. We were not rushed; service was prompt and not overreaching. Afterward we sat on the covered back deck facing Crow Creek on comfortable cushioned chairs entertained by the evening thunderstorm.

The Takeaway: Although noted as a renowned fishing lodge (Mike Lawson assisted Andre Puyans with his famous fly fishing schools for almost 30 years here) our interest is in the great dining experience in the ambiance of a 19^th century fishing lodge secluded in a well groomed rural setting on Crow Creek. Each weeknight offers a different fixed menu expertly prepared by resident chef; the food is superb. Go to  www.rickpicks.com for more photographs, other reviews, critiques and essays with links to area attractions and a more detailed review of rv parks as well as reviews of restaurants, etc.